Do I need to be an expert in what is being produced to be an effective project manager?

December 06, 2011 Latest News by Andrew Smith

Project management purists will argue that you need industry knowledge or technical expertise within the domain or area you are project managing. For example a construction project requires ‘s a background in engineering, a software development project in coding, a FMIS project a background in financials or accounting etc.

I say “bullocks” to that.

Reflecting on some recent project successes, some of the most successful projects I have delivered involved having absolutely no technical knowledge of the end product being produced. So that got me thinking, what made these a success and is there an ideal formula? 

So what do I think are the key characteristics that made these a success: 

Trust the process:

Not having product expertise means you’re only as good as the project process or method you are applying. If you can’t trust the process you’re applying then you’re in a world of trouble. This will sort out the ‘pretenders’ from effective project managers. This will mean more emphasis on getting things done through other people, so soft skill traits are more important then being able to read ‘a line of code’ (if it’s a software project) or understand what ‘weighted average capital’ mean’s (if it’s a Financial Systems project.)

Avoid having a play:

Having product knowledge usually means a desire to jump in and ‘have a look’ or ‘play’.   PM’s in this category end up getting diverted and want to be ‘hand’s on’. The danger in this is that you bring your own product ‘baggage’ which may end up hindering progress or you run the risk of getting caught up in unnecessary technical detail  vs focuing on what’s really important. I say leave the product design to the experts, and focus on just ‘managing’.

Stick to your role:

As in above, you’ve been brought in to just manage the project – so do just that and do it well. Leave the design, testing, technical tasks to the experts. Just facilitate the process.

Leaving the ego at home:

Don’t pretend to be a the ‘product expert – this is how you should do it’. Know when to tap into expertise and yet again your role is to facilitate the right outcomes. Don’t feel a need to be the technical ’decision maker’ – instead be the ‘decision facilitator’!

Comments (17)

Absolutely first rate and cobepr-eottompd, gentlemen!
Heck of a job there, it abseoutlly helps me out.
In the coaleicmtpd world we live in, it's good to find simple solutions.
This artilce is a home run, pure and simple!
The expirtese shines through. Thanks for taking the time to answer. http://vslfapom.com [url=http://pkuitypsdp.com]pkuitypsdp[/url] [link=http://gqcvmw.com]gqcvmw[/link]
I was sesurioly at DefCon 5 until I saw this post. http://efozqywp.com [url=http://dnjmuiqk.com]dnjmuiqk[/url] [link=http://uycovtjck.com]uycovtjck[/link]
Thanks for inoiudtcrng a little rationality into this debate. http://uejccnwgwc.com [url=http://wewcaile.com]wewcaile[/url] [link=http://jasashcnahz.com]jasashcnahz[/link]
Very true! Makes a change to see soemone spell it out like that. :) http://tdpgug.com [url=http://tmtcpjo.com]tmtcpjo[/url] [link=http://uqjnwtd.com]uqjnwtd[/link]
You got to push it-this esietnsal info that is! http://hitkoh.com [url=http://guvtsv.com]guvtsv[/url] [link=http://vlytvgwd.com]vlytvgwd[/link]
Kewl you should come up with that. Exnctleel!
An integlilent point of view, well expressed! Thanks!
I don't even know what to say, this made things so much eaires!
This shows real extperise. Thanks for the answer.

Wednesday

Deep thought! Thanks for coibnitutrng.

Shatrex

I just read your blog The Shattering and it made me recall an eisdope in my life quite similar. I was 23 yrs old, 7 months pregnant with my second child and just had the millionth fight with my then husband about his addiction, inability to keep a job, and total disregard for his family responsibilities. I was in hysterics, crying, ran out the door, ran four streets away to a small park, sat on a swing and sobbed uncontrollably(in the pouring rain). I thought the rain drowned out my sobs, but a nearby neighbor came out, invited me into their home, a complete stranger, to calm down. I sat awhile, then calmly returned home and continued to live in hell, until I got the strength to leave 5 yrs later. I guess something just snapped inside me thank God for that. I, too, survived, and so did my daughters who are now 37, 33, and 31. Keep on keepin' on life will get happy and you will be loved!

Add New Comment

*
Captcha text
Thanks for signing up!